January 15, 2011

Dr. Who and the Daleks



Data
Title: Dr. Who and the Daleks
Year: 1965 (UK); 1966 (US)
Length: 82 minutes
Director: Gordon Flemyng
Writer: Milton Subotsky, based on a TV serial by Terry Nation
Starring: Peter Cushing, Roy Castle, Jennie Linden, Roberta Tovey
Music: Malcolm Lockyer
I saw it: on video (rented from Greencine), yesterday
Synopsis: an absent-minded professor's invention transports him and three others to a post-nuclear alien world



My reaction
Concept:4/4 (Great)
Story:0/4 (Terrible) The adaptation is completely terrible; I seriously wonder if they had a script at all. Something's very wrong when a movie's writing makes Terry Nation look good.
Characters:1/4 (Bad) This area is really frustrating. The TV show had one of the best characters ever created, and some decent supporting characters. The movie doesn't just change them - it erases them, and leaves a vacuum.
Dialog:0/4 (Terrible) Two words: Dalek monologues.
Pacing:0/4 (Terrible) It's condensed from a three-hour serial, and it still manages to bore me silly.
Cinematography:3/4 (Good) One thing this movie has going for it - colorful, old-school technicolor.
Special effects/design:2/4 (Indifferent) I love the design. The special effects might actually be worse than the infamously low-budget TV show.
Acting:1/4 (Bad) Even Peter Cushing just does an impersonation of William Hartnell, contributing nothing worth seeing. The others are very bad.
Music:3/4 (Good)
Subjective Rating: 3/10 (Bad, 1/4 (Bad)). I'd assumed that all the hatred that Doctor Who fans have for this movie stemmed from its being too different from the TV show (imagine a nerd whining indignantly, "but that's not how it happened!"). And maybe that is why they hate it, but it doesn't matter because it's a crappy movie anyway. There's simply no sense of storytelling. The filmmakers' one and only goal was to put Daleks on film, in color, with enough semblance of a movie around it that people wouldn't demand their money back.
Objective Rating (Average):1.5/4 (Eh)


No comments:

Post a Comment